Payment Gateways for Small Online Stores: Stripe vs. PayPal vs. Square

For most small online stores, Stripe is the lowest-cost default for card payments, PayPal is worth adding as a second option because shoppers recognize it, and Square fits best when you also sell in person. The choice matters because Baymard Institute’s average of 50 studies puts cart abandonment at 70.22%, and 19% of shoppers say they did not trust the site with their card details. This guide compares the three payment gateways on fees, real order costs, and fit, using US rates published in 2026.

Quick answer: Stripe is usually the cheapest for online cards at 2.9% + 30¢. PayPal costs more per sale but reassures buyers. Square suits stores that also sell in person. Many small stores offer two options.

What Is a Payment Gateway, and Do You Need One?

A payment gateway is the service that securely passes a customer’s card details from your checkout page to the bank for approval, and every store that accepts cards online needs one. Stripe, PayPal, and Square each combine the gateway with payment processing, so a small store can start without arranging a separate merchant account. The gateway you pick shapes your fees, your checkout experience, and how quickly you get paid.

How Much Do Stripe, PayPal, and Square Charge?

On a US online card sale, Stripe charges 2.9% + 30¢, PayPal charges 2.99% + 49¢ for standard cards and 3.49% + 49¢ at PayPal Checkout, and Square charges 3.3% + 30¢ on its free plan. None of the three charges a monthly fee on its basic plan.

ProviderOnline card rateNotes
Stripe2.9% + 30¢Same rate for Apple Pay and Google Pay
PayPal2.99% + 49¢PayPal Checkout and Venmo cost 3.49% + 49¢
Square Free3.3% + 30¢Same rate for invoices and payment links
Square Plus ($49/month)2.9% + 30¢Lowers the online rate by 0.4 points

Rates change often. Square raised its free plan online rate from 2.9% to 3.3% in January 2026, so older comparison articles may be wrong. Confirm current rates on each provider’s pricing page before you commit.

What Do the Fees Look Like on Real Orders?

The fixed fee matters most on small orders, which is why PayPal’s 49¢ makes it the most expensive option on low-priced items. These fees are calculated from the published rates above:

Order sizeStripeSquare FreePayPal cardPayPal Checkout
$25$1.03$1.13$1.24$1.36
$50$1.75$1.95$1.99$2.24
$100$3.20$3.60$3.48$3.98

On a $25 order, PayPal Checkout takes 5.45% of the sale while Stripe takes 4.1%. For a store with 500 orders a month averaging $50, Stripe fees come to about $875 a month, versus about $1,118 if every order went through PayPal Checkout, a gap of roughly $2,900 a year. Shoppers split between methods in practice, so your real cost lands between the two.

Which Provider Fits Which Type of Store?

Choose Stripe for online-first stores, PayPal for added buyer familiarity, and Square for stores that also sell in person.

Stripe fits when:

  • Most sales happen online and card fees are your biggest cost
  • You want ACH bank payments at 0.8%, capped at $5

PayPal fits when:

  • You want a familiar button for shoppers who avoid typing card details
  • You want a quick second option next to a card gateway

Square fits when:

  • You also sell at markets, pop-ups, or a shop, where free-plan card rates are 2.6% + 15¢
  • Online sales pass about $12,250 a month, the point where the $49 Plus plan starts to save money

Should You Offer More Than One Payment Option?

Yes, most small stores should offer a card gateway plus one wallet, because limited payment choice costs sales. Baymard found that 9% of shoppers abandoned a cart because there were not enough payment methods, and 10% because their card was declined. With roughly 7 in 10 carts abandoned on average, including shoppers who were only browsing, even small checkout gains matter. A common pairing is Stripe for cards and PayPal as a second button, which gives you low card fees and a familiar fallback.

What Hidden Costs Should You Check?

Check dispute fees, international surcharges, and rate changes, because they add cost beyond the headline percentage:

  • Disputes: about $15 at Stripe and $20 at PayPal per chargeback
  • International cards: an extra 1.5% at Stripe and PayPal
  • Currency conversion: an extra 1% at Stripe
  • Rate changes: Square’s January 2026 increase shows fees can move mid-year

Payout timing and account reserve rules also vary, so read each provider’s terms before you rely on quick access to your sales.

How Do You Choose and Set One Up?

Estimate your average order value and monthly order count, calculate the fees on each option, and test checkout on a phone before launch. Your store platform must also support the gateway, which is worth asking any eCommerce website provider before you build. Then work through these steps:

  • Calculate fees at your own average order value
  • Confirm platform support and payout timing
  • Place a few small live orders on mobile
  • Refund them and check receipts and payouts

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Stripe cheaper than PayPal?

Usually, for online cards. Stripe’s 2.9% + 30¢ undercuts PayPal’s 2.99% + 49¢ for cards and 3.49% + 49¢ at PayPal Checkout, and the gap is widest on small orders.

Is Square good for an online store?

Yes, especially if you also sell in person. Its free plan charges 3.3% + 30¢ online, though, so higher-volume stores may save money on the paid Plus plan.

Can I use more than one gateway?

Yes. Many stores pair a card gateway with PayPal so shoppers can choose, as long as the store platform supports both.

Do I need a separate merchant account?

No. Stripe, PayPal, and Square each handle processing for you, so most small stores can start without one.

Final Thoughts

No single gateway wins every case. Stripe usually leads on online card cost, PayPal adds shopper familiarity, and Square helps when you sell in person too. Before you decide:

  • Calculate fees at your own average order value
  • Confirm your store platform supports the gateway
  • Offer at least one alternative to cards

Comments

  • No comments yet.
  • Add a comment